torque v. stretch

  • Godfrey
  • Godfrey's Avatar
  • Offline
  • User
  • User
    Registered
  • Posts: 210
  • Thanks: 10

Re: torque v. stretch

12 Feb 2012 11:17
#503453
I always liked the guys who have it down to where they can tighten it till their eye twitches and its good.
1981 650CSR frame

1980 KZ750E engine

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

  • 650ed
  • 650ed's Avatar
  • Offline
  • User
  • User
    Registered
  • Posts: 15334
  • Thanks: 2832

Re: torque v. stretch

12 Feb 2012 11:41 - 12 Feb 2012 12:27
#503459
LarryC wrote: Here's a good example for you all.

The rear axle nut has a torque spec. It's also in many cases and castle nut and the axle has holes for a cotter pin.

So when you torque the castle nut to spec and the holes in the axle don't line up with the castle nut, what are you going to do....

a] Get out the Drill
b] Take it back apart, rotate the axle a tad and try again
c] Try using a shim behind the nut

:whistle:

How tight do you tighten:

* the screws for the handle bar switches?
* the nuts on the cable adjusters?
* How tight should the seat latch grasp the lock bar on the seat?
* turn signal and tail light lens screws?
* the caps on the valve stems? [some are plastic - some are metal]
* the screw on cover of the brake master cylinder

Sometimes you just have to

Attachment images_2012-02-12.jpg not found


and hope for good results

If you're going to use a cotter pin why would you put a nut on the axle? Isn't the pin supposed to keep the axle from pulling out? :woohoo: Same goes for cylinder head nuts, use cotter pins and you won't need to bother finding a torque wrench. ;)
1977 KZ650-C1 Original Owner - Stock (with additional invisible FIAMM horn)
Last edit: 12 Feb 2012 12:27 by 650ed.

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

  • Patton
  • Patton's Avatar
  • Offline
  • KZr Legend
  • KZr Legend
    Registered
  • Posts: 18564
  • Thanks: 2103

Re: torque v. stretch

12 Feb 2012 11:41
#503460
Handlebar clamps, when desiring to achieve the "perfect riding position," snug enough to hold okay in the best-guess initial position, but allow movement up and down during test ride.

Upon attaining the world's finest riding position, pull over to a stop, and snug 'em up a little more, to the recommended Black Forest setting.

This doesn't work as well with clip-ons.

Good Fortune! :)
1973 Z1
KZ900 LTD

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

  • Breaker19
  • Breaker19's Avatar
  • Offline
  • User
  • User
    Registered
  • Posts: 88
  • Thanks: 2

Re: torque v. stretch

12 Feb 2012 14:10
#503478
faffi wrote: Some bolts have properties that makes them very flexible, more like a rubber band. Others will snap before they stretch much. Torque specifications are usually to make sure something doesn't leak and/or fall apart without disturbing the shape and/or snap treads. If you overtighten the bolts on the engine covers, your greatest risk is stripping treads followed by disforming of the cover itself, which can cause leaks. Stick to the recommended values, or a little less if you use paste on the treads.

If you can measure stretch and know that the bolts in question are factory AND unused, it will give the most accurate torque setting because it will be oblivious to friction - which can vary enormously, giving false torque values. Unless otherwise specified, torque settings are for dry bolts with fresh treads. Lube will lead to overtightening, bad/rusty to undertightening.

I think you're referring to "torque to yield" bolts. Generally speaking, you'll find these in cylinder heads on more late-model engines. It's easy to identify if the torque spec shows a certain ft lb torque followed by another turn in degrees, like you said. I am unaware of any small fasteners that are TTY. Harley's have a TTY bolt on the primary (compensator) bolt off the crank, I read a TSB on this regarding the compensator bolt on 2007 and up 96 CID's, but for vintage Asian bikes, I am unaware of any TTY fasteners. I know on the KZ1100, the torque spec for the stator rotor is a set ft lb, which gets backed off and torqued again, but this doesn't appear to be a TTY, it's to set the rotor on the tapered shaft and then finish torqued. There is no degree added torque so it's not a TTY bolt.

Personally, I don't use a torque wrench for any small fasteners, I know when to stop cranking, but I've been wrenching for 35 years now on various stuff..

On thread lubricant, there are a couple schools of thought. Never Seize is essentially designed to prevent a fastener from corroding where the threads on the fastener and the part they are screwed into, are dissimilar metals; usually due to some sort of electrolysis or simple rusting, depending upon the environment. It's different from a material designed for the torque spec of a bolt, like ARP's thread lubricant. However, for small fasteners, I think Never Seize or similar graphite-based products are fine for helping assume a proper torque value. Thread lubricant for head bolts, etc. like ARP's product, is designed to be used with their fasteners which are specially cut; not necessarily undercut threads, but a special thread pitch -- which is designed into the fastener to achieve the desired results. So, it really depends on exactly what the fastener purpose is and what the rated torque spec is. ARP usually has a spec for when their thread lube is used, as opposed to motor oil on the threads. The motor oil spec is higher because the friction is greater with that material.

Check out this paragraph from the ARP fasteners technical site:

Our investigation has proven that installed stretch is dependent not only on the pitch of the thread and the degree of rotation, but also on the amount of compression of the clamped components, the type of lubrication, the length of the male fastener, and the amount of engaged thread. It's important to note that for the same degree of rotation, the amount of bolt stretch will be critically different between an aluminum or cast iron cylinder head, or when installing a steel main cap on a cast iron or aluminum block. Furthermore, there is a significant difference in stretch between the long and short cylinder head bolts or studs on the same head. The torque angle method can be accurate – but only if each individual application has been previously calibrated by direct measurement of bolt stretch. If you do employ the torque angle method, it's best to begin calibrating rotation from some small measured torque rather than the first point of contact with the work face. To achieve optimum accuracy, always use ARP Ultra-Torque® fastener assembly lubricant whenever possible.

So, in summary, there's a lot of engineering to machining threads and fastener material. Low grade steel fasteners for engine covers and such shouldn't burn too much brain-power figuring out a torque methodology. Just screw it in and tighten. Use an accurate torque wrench as Patton said. And when the service manual specifies for a torque to yield, just remember you must use a new fastener anytime a TTY is loosened or removed.
2003 Suzuki DR650 Dual-Sport
1982 KZ1100A2 - GONE! Traded-in for a '12 Concours 14
www.facebook.com/pages/Moto-Resto/169238286503527

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

  • jonnybravo
  • jonnybravo's Avatar
  • Offline
  • Banned
  • Banned
    Registered
  • Posts: 518
  • Thanks: 18

Re: torque v. stretch

12 Feb 2012 15:19
#503483
LarryC wrote: Here's a good example for you all.

The rear axle nut has a torque spec. It's also in many cases and castle nut and the axle has holes for a cotter pin.

So when you torque the castle nut to spec and the holes in the axle don't line up with the castle nut, what are you going to do....

a] Get out the Drill
b] Take it back apart, rotate the axle a tad and try again
c] Try using a shim behind the nut
g

funny u should mention that, there was a thread awhile back where someone said that tightening to spec on axle nut could not pinch in rear swingarn, myself and Jim said yes, ur thoughts Larry

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

  • andy9802gt
  • andy9802gt's Avatar
  • Offline
  • User
  • User
    Registered
  • If it tastes that good, eat it yourself.
  • Posts: 695
  • Thanks: 19

Re: torque v. stretch

12 Feb 2012 15:41
#503487
jonnybravo wrote:
LarryC wrote: Here's a good example for you all.

The rear axle nut has a torque spec. It's also in many cases and castle nut and the axle has holes for a cotter pin.

So when you torque the castle nut to spec and the holes in the axle don't line up with the castle nut, what are you going to do....

a] Get out the Drill
b] Take it back apart, rotate the axle a tad and try again
c] Try using a shim behind the nut
g

funny u should mention that, there was a thread awhile back where someone said that tightening to spec on axle nut could not pinch in rear swingarn, myself and Jim said yes, ur thoughts Larry

Heres my thought, of course it can pinch the swingarm that's one of the functions of the spacers aside from centering the wheel.
'78 KZ1075 LTD
stage 1 head by Larry Cavanaugh
race built crank by John Pearson
Mikuni rs34's
k410 cams
back cut tranny
8" over D&G swinger
proving once again that age and treachery is better than youth and enthusiasm

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

  • faffi
  • faffi's Avatar
  • Offline
  • User
  • User
    Registered
  • Posts: 554
  • Thanks: 36

Re: torque v. stretch

12 Feb 2012 17:38
#503512
Virtually everybody that tighten stuff by feel overtighten. Use a torque wrench and check your work.

I, too, tighten a lot of bolts sans torque wench, but delicate stuff as well as critical stuff AND stuff that goes on and off frequently pays to use a calibrated wrench on IMO.
1977 KZ650B1
1980 F1 engine
B1 3-phase alternator
B1 Points ignition

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

  • notaduc
  • notaduc's Avatar
  • Offline
  • User
  • User
    Registered
  • Posts: 297
  • Thanks: 3

Re: torque v. stretch

12 Feb 2012 18:29
#503536
Garn wrote: Here's one..... Do you put more torque on a bolt with anti-seize or moly compound on the thread and under the head of bolt/ screw surface.
RegardZ.
Ps. Agree 6mm threads don't need a torque wrench.

arp-bolts.com/pages/technical_torque_metric.shtml
1980 (mostly) KZ1000

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

  • Breaker19
  • Breaker19's Avatar
  • Offline
  • User
  • User
    Registered
  • Posts: 88
  • Thanks: 2

Re: torque v. stretch

12 Feb 2012 19:02
#503542
notaduc wrote:
Garn wrote: Here's one..... Do you put more torque on a bolt with anti-seize or moly compound on the thread and under the head of bolt/ screw surface.
RegardZ.
Ps. Agree 6mm threads don't need a torque wrench.

arp-bolts.com/pages/technical_torque_metric.shtml

No. In fact, with ARP head bolts (automotive), you use less torque, depending upon the fastener and the application. For example: My step-son's 87 Toyota Supra Turbo MKIII, when I did his motor with ARP head studs, 80 ft lbs with motor oil on the threads, and I think it was 60 with the ARP lube.

For general purpose fasteners that require a torque value, you should get a more accurate torque by using a lubrication medium on the threads. So, in essence, you'll be measuring the truer torque instead of the friction of the threads.
2003 Suzuki DR650 Dual-Sport
1982 KZ1100A2 - GONE! Traded-in for a '12 Concours 14
www.facebook.com/pages/Moto-Resto/169238286503527

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

  • 650ed
  • 650ed's Avatar
  • Offline
  • User
  • User
    Registered
  • Posts: 15334
  • Thanks: 2832

Re: torque v. stretch

12 Feb 2012 19:46
#503549
Breaker19 wrote:
notaduc wrote:
Garn wrote: Here's one..... Do you put more torque on a bolt with anti-seize or moly compound on the thread and under the head of bolt/ screw surface.
RegardZ.
Ps. Agree 6mm threads don't need a torque wrench.

arp-bolts.com/pages/technical_torque_metric.shtml

No. In fact, with ARP head bolts (automotive), you use less torque, depending upon the fastener and the application. For example: My step-son's 87 Toyota Supra Turbo MKIII, when I did his motor with ARP head studs, 80 ft lbs with motor oil on the threads, and I think it was 60 with the ARP lube.

For general purpose fasteners that require a torque value, you should get a more accurate torque by using a lubrication medium on the threads. So, in essence, you'll be measuring the truer torque instead of the friction of the threads.

Not so. The torque values are calculated based on fasteners with clean dry threads. Here's a clip from the Kawasaki Service Manual regarding the use of the torque specification chart:

Attachment Torqueinstructions.jpg not found

1977 KZ650-C1 Original Owner - Stock (with additional invisible FIAMM horn)

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

  • Breaker19
  • Breaker19's Avatar
  • Offline
  • User
  • User
    Registered
  • Posts: 88
  • Thanks: 2

Re: torque v. stretch

12 Feb 2012 19:53
#503550
650ed wrote:
Breaker19 wrote:
notaduc wrote:
Garn wrote: Here's one..... Do you put more torque on a bolt with anti-seize or moly compound on the thread and under the head of bolt/ screw surface.
RegardZ.
Ps. Agree 6mm threads don't need a torque wrench.

arp-bolts.com/pages/technical_torque_metric.shtml

No. In fact, with ARP head bolts (automotive), you use less torque, depending upon the fastener and the application. For example: My step-son's 87 Toyota Supra Turbo MKIII, when I did his motor with ARP head studs, 80 ft lbs with motor oil on the threads, and I think it was 60 with the ARP lube.

For general purpose fasteners that require a torque value, you should get a more accurate torque by using a lubrication medium on the threads. So, in essence, you'll be measuring the truer torque instead of the friction of the threads.

Not so. The torque values are calculated based on fasteners with clean dry threads. Here's a clip from the Kawasaki Service Manual regarding the use of the torque specification chart:

Attachment Torqueinstructions.jpg not found


OK, semantics. For THOSE particular fasteners, yes. I was answering in general, using ARP as an example.
2003 Suzuki DR650 Dual-Sport
1982 KZ1100A2 - GONE! Traded-in for a '12 Concours 14
www.facebook.com/pages/Moto-Resto/169238286503527

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

  • 650ed
  • 650ed's Avatar
  • Offline
  • User
  • User
    Registered
  • Posts: 15334
  • Thanks: 2832

Re: torque v. stretch

12 Feb 2012 20:10
#503553
Garn wrote: Here's one..... Do you put more torque on a bolt with anti-seize or moly compound on the thread and under the head of bolt/ screw surface.
RegardZ.
Ps. Agree 6mm threads don't need a torque wrench.

Yes and no; it kinda varies depending on which 6mm fastener. Example; the cam cap bolts are 6mm and many folks have managed to strip the threads in the cylinder head by overtightening them. I would suggest that because of the leverage produced by a wrench any fasteners with a hex head that are threaded into the aluminum engine would be good candidates for using a torque wrench (although I am sure there are some folks with lots of experience can judge the difference between 95 and 100 inch pounds just by "feel"). On the other hand, pan head screws with JIS cross heads would be less likely to strip because of the reduced leverage one has using a screwdriver vs. a ratchet. JMO. Ed
1977 KZ650-C1 Original Owner - Stock (with additional invisible FIAMM horn)

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

Moderators: Street Fighter LTD
Powered by Kunena Forum